How to avoid student loan scams
Student loan scams typically demand upfront fees, request FSA ID passwords, or guarantee loan forgiveness—all red flags that legitimate services never exhibit. If you see any of these, it is a scam, and you should verify the company immediately at StudentAid.gov. In this guide, you will learn how to identify common scam types, recognize warning signs, verify legitimate services, and take action if targeted.
Navigating student debt is stressful enough without the added threat of malicious actors trying to take advantage of borrowers. Scammers prey on the complexity of the financial aid system, targeting both students managing their own debt and parents trying to support their families. Whether you are a student just entering repayment or a parent managing Parent PLUS loans, the desire for relief can sometimes make fraudulent offers look appealing.
Understanding the mechanics of these scams is the first step toward financial safety. By knowing exactly what legitimate communication looks like versus what fraudsters offer, you can confidently manage your student loans without fear. This guide provides the practical tools and knowledge needed to distinguish between helpful resources and harmful traps, ensuring your family’s financial future remains secure.
Context: why student loan scams are on the rise
Student loan debt is the second-largest category of consumer debt in the United States, creating a massive market for scammers to exploit. As of early 2025, millions of borrowers are navigating a complex landscape of repayment plans, forgiveness applications, and servicing changes. Scammers thrive on this confusion, often timing their surges in activity to coincide with major policy announcements, FAFSA deadlines, or the resumption of payments.
These bad actors target borrowers who are looking for relief or are unfamiliar with official government processes. They utilize sophisticated communication methods, including official-looking emails, text messages, social media advertisements, and aggressive phone calls. By impersonating the Department of Education or loan servicers, they create a false sense of authority to extract payments or personal data.
Why it matters
- Financial Loss: According to the Federal Trade Commission, consumers lose millions of dollars annually to debt relief scams.
- Identity Theft: When scammers obtain your FSA ID credentials, they can hijack your financial aid account, diverting funds or taking out loans in your name.
- Default Risk: Borrowers often stop paying their legitimate servicer because a scammer promised to handle it, leading to delinquency, default, and credit damage.
Recognizing that scammers manipulate emotions—specifically hope for forgiveness and fear of debt—helps you stay vigilant. While the tactics change, the underlying goal remains the same: to profit from your need for financial stability.
Common types of student loan scams
While scammers constantly evolve their scripts, most fraud falls into a few specific categories. Understanding these distinct types helps you recognize when an offer is too good to be true.
These companies claim they can lower your monthly payments, consolidate your loans, or negotiate with lenders on your behalf—for a price. They often charge high enrollment fees or monthly maintenance fees for services that you can do for yourself for free. They may present themselves as “document preparation services” to bypass legal restrictions, but their primary goal is collecting fees rather than actually helping you manage debt.
This is one of the most pervasive types of fraud. The scammer promises to issue a loan or provide a service, but requires you to pay a fee beforehand. They may call it a “processing fee,” “insurance fee,” or “origination fee.” Once the money is sent, usually via wire transfer or gift cards, the scammer disappears, and the promised loan or service never materializes.
Scammers aggressively market “Biden-Harris Loan Forgiveness” or similar programs, claiming they can guarantee your eligibility. These scams often mimic legitimate programs like Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) or Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) forgiveness. They promise to wipe out your balance immediately if you pay a fee or provide your personal information, exploiting the news cycle regarding legitimate government relief efforts.
Phishing involves unsolicited emails, texts, or calls that appear to come from the Department of Education, “Federal Student Aid,” or your specific loan servicer. These communications often use urgent language claiming there is a problem with your account or that you are eligible for a new benefit. The goal is to trick you into clicking a malicious link or revealing sensitive personal information like your Social Security number.
Some scams are designed solely to harvest your Federal Student Aid (FSA) ID username and password. With these credentials, criminals can log into your StudentAid.gov account to divert refund checks, consolidate loans without your permission, or take out new loans in your name. This goes beyond simple financial loss and can take years to resolve.
These scams involve companies posing as law firms that promise to sue your student loan lender to settle your debt. They often claim that your loans are illegal or that they can negotiate a “settlement” for pennies on the dollar. In reality, they collect heavy legal retainers and do little to no work, leaving you with the original debt and less money in your pocket.
Decision: red flags that signal a scam
You do not need to be a financial expert to spot a scam. Most fraudulent operations rely on specific tactics that legitimate organizations never use. If you encounter any of the following warning signs, stop communication immediately.
| Red Flag | Why It Is a Scam | What To Do Instead |
|---|---|---|
| Demands for Upfront Fees | It is illegal for debt relief companies to collect fees before settling or altering your debt. Legitimate help is free. | Contact your loan servicer directly for free assistance. |
| Guarantees of Forgiveness | No company can guarantee forgiveness; eligibility depends on strict federal criteria that third parties cannot influence. | Check your eligibility for PSLF or IDR at StudentAid.gov. |
| Pressure Tactics (“Act Now”) | Scammers create false urgency to panic you into making a mistake. Legitimate programs have clear, public deadlines. | Take your time. Verify claims on official .gov websites. |
| Requests for FSA ID Password | Your FSA ID serves as your legal signature. The Department of Education and servicers will NEVER ask for your password. | Never share your FSA ID. If you did, change it immediately. |
| Requests for Power of Attorney | Scammers want legal authority to make changes to your account without your oversight. This is unnecessary for loan help. | Manage your own account through your servicer’s portal. |
| Claims of “Special Access” | No private company has a special relationship with the Department of Education that gets you a better deal. | Use the free Loan Simulator tool at StudentAid.gov. |
| Unsolicited Contact | If a company contacts you out of the blue knowing your loan balance, they likely bought your data from a marketing list. | Hang up. Call your servicer using the number on their official site. |
| Requests to Stop Paying Servicer | Scammers want you to pay them instead. Stopping payments to your servicer will result in delinquency and default. | Continue paying your servicer while investigating options. |
Source: Federal Trade Commission and StudentAid.gov (Data as of January 2025)
The Golden Rule: If an offer sounds too good to be true—such as complete debt elimination overnight for a fee—it is a scam. Legitimate student loan relief takes time, paperwork, and adherence to federal regulations.
How to verify legitimate student loan services
Knowing how to verify who you are dealing with is the most effective defense against fraud. Legitimate organizations operate with transparency and are easily verifiable through official government channels.
According to StudentAid.gov, official emails from the Department of Education will only come from addresses ending in .gov, specifically noreply@studentaid.gov, noreply@debtrelief.studentaid.gov, or ed.gov. While scammers can sometimes “spoof” email addresses, they cannot fake the destination of the links inside. Always hover over links before clicking to ensure they lead to a .gov domain.
Borrowers often fall for scams because they aren’t sure who actually holds their loans. To verify your servicer:
- Log in to your account at StudentAid.gov using your FSA ID.
- Navigate to the “My Aid” dashboard.
- Scroll down to the “My Loan Servicers” section.
- This will list the specific company (e.g., MOHELA, Nelnet, Aidvantage) assigned to handle your loans, along with their official contact information.
Any communication claiming to be from a servicer not listed on your dashboard is likely fraudulent. For more details on navigating this, see our guide to federal loan servicers.
If you are considering using a private company for advice, rigorous vetting is essential. Check the company’s name with the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and your state attorney general’s office to see if there are complaints against them. Additionally, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) maintains a database of enforcement actions against fraudulent debt relief operations.
Legitimate vs. Scam Quick Check:
- Legitimate: Directs you to StudentAid.gov forms; encourages you to contact your servicer; charges no fees for federal program applications.
- Scam: Asks for your FSA ID password; demands credit card numbers over the phone; uses aggressive language like “Final Notice”; charges enrollment fees.
Free legitimate resources for student loan help
The most important thing to remember is that you do not need to pay for help with your student loans. The federal government and nonprofit organizations provide free assistance that is safer and more effective than any paid “debt relief” service.
- Income-Driven Repayment (IDR) Plans: You can apply for plans that cap payments based on your income and family size for free at StudentAid.gov. See our guide to IDR plans for details.
- Loan Forgiveness: Applications for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF), Teacher Loan Forgiveness, and Total and Permanent Disability Discharge are all free. Learn more in our PSLF guide.
- FSA Ombudsman Group: If you have a dispute with your loan servicer that isn’t being resolved, the Federal Student Aid Ombudsman Group is a neutral, confidential, and free resource to help you resolve the issue.
If you need personalized guidance on budgeting and debt management, look for a certified student loan counselor. The National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) can connect you with accredited nonprofit agencies that offer free or low-cost counseling. These counselors are vetted and trained to look out for your financial best interests.
Understanding the trade-offs
It is critical to distinguish between federal and private options:
- Federal Loans: Offer IDR plans, PSLF, and generous deferment options. Third-party companies cannot negotiate these terms or add benefits that don’t already exist in law.
- Private Loans: Do not qualify for federal forgiveness or IDR. While legitimate private lenders offer customer support, they have different hardship options.
- The Bottom Line: Anything a paid service claims they can do for your federal loans, you can do yourself for free.
According to Betsy Mayotte, president of The Institute of Student Loan Advisors, “In general, federal loans should be your first stop, but private loans can be appropriate when you’ve maxed out your federal eligibility.” This highlights the importance of exhausting free federal resources and protections before seeking other financial solutions.
If you have maximized federal options and are considering private refinancing or additional funding, ensure you only work with vetted, transparent lenders.
- Federal First: Always exhaust federal aid and subsidized loans before turning to private options.
- Check Rates: You can check rates with a soft credit pull that does not affect your credit score.
- Cosigners: Adding a creditworthy cosigner may help students qualify for better rates.
Compare private student loan rates from 8+ lenders in minutes
What to do if you’ve been scammed or suspect a scam
If you suspect you have engaged with a scammer, acting quickly can minimize the damage. Do not feel ashamed—scammers are professionals at deception. Take the following steps immediately to protect your identity and finances.
If you shared your FSA ID credentials, go to StudentAid.gov and change your password immediately. Review your account activity to ensure no unauthorized changes were made, such as a change in contact email or mailing address. Contact your actual loan servicer to alert them of the potential fraud so they can flag your account for suspicious activity.
If you authorized automatic withdrawals or paid fees to a scammer, contact your bank or credit card issuer immediately. Request to stop all future payments to that company and dispute the previous charges as fraudulent. The sooner you report the transaction, the higher the likelihood of recovering funds.
Filing a complaint helps federal agencies shut down scam operations and may help you establish a record of the fraud.
- Federal Trade Commission (FTC): Report fraud at ReportFraud.ftc.gov. This is the primary clearinghouse for scam reports.
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB): Submit a complaint at consumerfinance.gov/complaint regarding financial products and services.
- State Attorney General: Contact your state’s consumer protection office, as they often handle local enforcement actions.
- U.S. Department of Education OIG: If federal funds were involved or your FSA ID was compromised, file a report with the Office of Inspector General.
If you shared sensitive personal information like your Social Security number, you are at risk of identity theft. Place a free fraud alert or credit freeze on your reports with the three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) to prevent scammers from opening new accounts in your name.
Frequently asked questions about student loan scams
Can student loan forgiveness be guaranteed?
No. No private company can guarantee forgiveness approval. Eligibility is determined solely by federal regulations and your specific loan type. Any company promising guaranteed results is running a scam.
Should I ever share my FSA ID password?
Never. Your FSA ID is legally equivalent to your signature. Legitimate loan servicers and Department of Education representatives will never ask for your password. Keep these credentials private.
Are student loan consolidation companies legitimate?
Some private companies offer consolidation for a fee, but this is rarely necessary. You can consolidate federal loans for free through a Direct Consolidation Loan at StudentAid.gov. Paying a third party to fill out this paperwork is a waste of money.
How do I know if a call about my student loans is real?
If you receive an unexpected call about your loans, do not give out any information. Hang up and call your loan servicer directly using the phone number listed on their official website or on StudentAid.gov.
Can I get my money back if I paid a scam company?
It is difficult, but possible. You should immediately dispute the charges with your bank or credit card company. Reporting the fraud to the FTC and your state attorney general can also assist in potential restitution efforts if authorities take legal action against the scammers.
Are there any legitimate paid student loan services?
While financial advisors can help with overall financial planning, you generally do not need to pay for student loan specific services. Enrollment in IDR plans, forgiveness programs, and consolidation is always free through federal channels.
Protecting yourself and your family from student loan scams requires vigilance, but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By relying on official sources and pausing to verify offers, you can navigate repayment safely. Remember these key takeaways:
- Never pay upfront fees: Legitimate help for federal student loans is always free.
- Guard your credentials: Your FSA ID password is for your eyes only—never share it.
- Verify before acting: Check every company against the BBB, CFPB, and StudentAid.gov.
- Use official channels: Manage your loans directly through your assigned servicer and StudentAid.gov.
- Report suspicious activity: If something feels off, report it to the FTC and CFPB immediately.
You have the power to manage your student debt effectively without falling victim to fraud. Utilizing free federal resources is the best way to ensure your loans are handled correctly. However, if you have explored all federal options and still require financial solutions, ensure you are looking at legitimate, vetted providers.
- Maximize Federal Protections: Always use federal loans and repayment plans first.
- Vetted Lenders: Private lenders on comparison platforms undergo review to ensure legitimacy.
- Safe Comparison: Using a comparison tool with a soft credit check allows you to view rates without risk.
- Cosigner Benefits: For students, a creditworthy cosigner can be the key to securing safe, lower-interest financing.
Ready to explore legitimate private loan options? Compare rates from 8+ trusted lenders in minutes (Trusted by 50,000+ families)
For more information on managing your education debt safely, visit our Student Loans Hub.
Many or all of the products presented on this page are from sponsors or partners who pay us. This compensation may influence which products we include, as well as how, where, and in what order a product appears on the page.
References and resources
Keep these official resources handy to verify information and manage your loans safely:
- StudentAid.gov: The official U.S. Department of Education website for managing federal student loans, applying for IDR, and accessing your account.
- ReportFraud.ftc.gov: The Federal Trade Commission’s dedicated portal for reporting scams and fraud.
- ConsumerFinance.gov: The CFPB website offers educational resources and a complaint system for financial products.
- NFCC.org: The National Foundation for Credit Counseling connects borrowers with certified, legitimate nonprofit counselors.
- State Attorneys General: Find your state’s consumer protection office to report local fraud or verify business complaints.
